Critics compare without reading both side by side

Most of the critics who talk about the influence of Beat generation on the Hungry generation poets of Bengal have not read the works of Malay Roychoudhury, Subhas Ghosh, Pradip Choudhuri, Subimal Basak, Subo Acharya, Saileswar Ghose and others. Those who write in English are completely Hungry-illiterate and even then they compare the Hungry generation with the Beat poets and writers. Most of the Hungry generation works have not been translated in English. In that case, how come they compare the Beats with the Hungries ?
                                         
                        Pradip Choudhuri on right. Arun Banik on left.
                                            Arun Banik was killed by political goons. 
                                                                        

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Beat writers and poets were dropouts whereas Hungries were not

Image
The Beat writers and poets were social dropouts, some evaded the Vietnam war and became Beatniks whereas the Hungries were not dropouts. The Hungries were from the cornered subaltern section of society, they rather wanted to be included in the Bengali culture. Hungries protested against the West Bengal and Indian Establishment by issuing manifesto, There has been no manifesto of the Beat generation. The Beats were not a cohesive group like the Hungries.                                             
Read more

Hungryalists and Beat Generation : Maitreyee B Chowdhury interviewed by Michael Liminos

Image
  Posted by Michael Limnios Blues Network on February 4, 2019 at 6:30pm "Throughout the world, poetry and music have been forerunners in challenging the mindsets of people. Irrespective of the genre and language both music and poetry have constantly motivated people into thinking differently, into rising in revolt against mediocre or oppressive thought processes." Maitreyee B Chowdhury: Bangalore Blues Maitreyee B Chowdhury is a Bangalore based poet and writer. She has three books to her credit- ‘Uttam Kumar and Suchitra Sen: Bengali Cinema’s First Couple’ and ‘Where Even the Present is Ancient: Benaras’. In the year 2013, ‘Uttam Kumar and Suchitra Sen: Bengali Cinema’s First Couple’ was nominated for the Crossword Book Awards, 2013 (Non Fiction category). Maitreyee is organiser of Bengaluru Poetry Festival, and poetry and fiction editor of The Bangalore Review, a literary journal. Maitreyee’s writings can be...
Read more

The Beats were 'Orientalists' whereas the Hungries were not 'Occidentalists'

Image
The Beats were, what Edward Said called 'Orientalists'. This may be proved from the photographs of the paupers, lepers, half naked sadhus, lame men in Allen Ginsberg's 'India Journals'. Allen Ginsberg was interested in such photographs only which he sold to Western readers through his book. He met all sorts of Hindu sadhus in India and ultimately adopted Buddhism, changing the sect twice. Same is the case with other Beats who got interested in Buddhism.  One may wonder how come there were always photographers and reporters to display Allen Ginsberg's 'Orientalism' to the Western Press.  When the reporters arrived at his Benares room he took them for photo opportunities. His Blake vision disappeared thereafter. The Hungries, almost all of them, though born in orthodox Hindu families, turned out to be atheists.                                             ...
Read more